Is Blue Topaz Or Aquamarine More Valuable?

In the intricate and fascinating world of gemstones, understanding value plays a key role. This knowledge assists in making informed decisions, whether you're an avid collector, a one-time buyer looking for a meaningful gift, or someone seeking a unique piece for personal adornment. In this blog post, we, at Perry's Diamonds & Estate Jewelry, turn the spotlight on two beautiful blue gemstones: Blue Topaz and Aquamarine. We'll dissect their intrinsic and market values, providing a comprehensive view of what makes these gemstones unique.

Basics of Gemstones

Gemstones are the wonders of Mother Nature, formed naturally in the earth's crust under specific conditions of temperature, pressure, and chemistry. Among the diverse range of gemstones, Blue Topaz and Aquamarine shine distinctly in their captivating shades of blue. While these gemstones may look similar in color at first glance, the process of their formation, market value, and consumer demand tell a different story.

Blue Topaz

Blue Topaz, a variant of silicate mineral topaz, is typically colorless in its pure form. However, due to natural radiation and artificial treatment, it takes on various hues, with blue being the most common. The primary reasons for its popularity are:

  • Its affordability compared to many other gemstones
  • Its availability in a wide range of blue shades
  • Its durability, which makes it ideal for a variety of jewelry pieces


Aquamarine is a gemstone-quality transparent variety of beryl, known for its delicate blue or blue-green color that is reminiscent of the sea. Aquamarine's allure lies in:

  • Its unique, calming color that ranges from sky blue to deep sea blue
  • Its status as a birthstone for March makes it a popular gift choice
  • Its durability and hardness, similar to Topaz, make it suitable for daily wear

Blue Topaz: A Detailed Look

Blue Topaz is an incredibly versatile gemstone, prized for its range of colors and its durability. From the vibrant, captivating hues of Swiss Blue to the alluring, deep tones of London Blue, this gemstone has a shade for every taste and occasion.

Factors Influencing Blue Topaz Value

The value of a Blue Topaz is not a product of a single factor but rather a combination of various attributes:

  • Color: The darker, more intense the blue, the higher the value. London Blue, with its deep blue hue, is the most sought-after.
  • Clarity: Blue Topaz gemstones are expected to be eye-clean, meaning no inclusions should be visible to the naked eye.
  • Cut: An excellent cut that maximizes the gemstone's brilliance adds to the overall value.
  • Carat Weight: Larger stones are rarer and hence, more valuable.

Market Trends and Demand for Blue Topaz

Given its affordability and availability, Blue Topaz has carved its place in the jewelry market. From our extensive collection of antique and estate jewelry at Perry's Diamonds & Estate Jewelry, we have observed that Blue Topaz continues to enjoy popularity due to its versatility in design and accessibility for a range of budgets.

Aquamarine: A Detailed Look

Aquamarine is celebrated not just for its serene, calming hues, reminiscent of the sea, but also for the symbolism it carries. As the birthstone for March, it represents youth, hope, and health. This symbolism, combined with its aesthetic appeal, gives Aquamarine its unique allure.

Factors Influencing Aquamarine Value

Much like Blue Topaz, several factors affect the value of an Aquamarine:

  • Color: Aquamarines with a rich, deep blue color command the highest prices.
  • Clarity: Most Aquamarines are eye-clean and any visible inclusions decrease their value.
  • Cut: A well-cut Aquamarine will enhance its color and overall appearance.
  • Carat Weight: Larger, high-quality Aquamarines are rare, thus driving up their value.

Market Trends and Demand for Aquamarine

Despite commanding a higher price point compared to Blue Topaz, Aquamarine remains in high demand. Its tranquil color and symbolic value appeal to a wide range of consumers. As antique and estate jewelers, we often come across stunning Aquamarine pieces that make a lasting impression.

Direct Comparison: Blue Topaz vs Aquamarine

Despite their similarities in color, Blue Topaz and Aquamarine have notable differences in their physical properties and market values. Aquamarine is generally considered more valuable due to its natural color and relative rarity, but Blue Topaz's affordability and variety of colors make it a popular choice for many consumers.

Role of Treatments in Value

The value of these gemstones is influenced significantly by treatments. Most Blue Topaz in the market undergoes heat and radiation treatment to achieve the desired blue shade. Aquamarine, on the other hand, is often heat-treated to intensify its blue color and remove greenish tones.

Factors Beyond Intrinsic Value

The value of a gemstone is not solely based on its inherent properties. Branding, marketing, symbolic or historical significance, and collector interest also play pivotal roles. With a team of GIA Graduate Gemologists and personal property appraisers at Perry's Diamonds & Estate Jewelry, we possess the expertise to consider these nuanced factors in our appraisals.

Case Studies

Through our rich history of buying, selling, trading, appraising, and repairing jewelry, we've been privileged to encounter an array of Blue Topaz and Aquamarine pieces. Each piece holds a unique story, exemplifying the distinct value of these two captivating gemstones.


Every gemstone has its unique charm and value proposition. While Aquamarine generally commands a higher market value due to its natural color and rarity, Blue Topaz continues to be a popular choice due to its affordability, range of blue hues, and versatility.

Whether you are looking for custom jewelry designs featuring these gemstones, or you require an insurance appraisal for your existing collection, Perry's Diamonds & Estate Jewelry is here to serve. We encourage you to schedule an appointment or visit our showroom to explore our vast and exquisite collection. As a family-owned business with deep roots in the industry, we promise an experience that combines professional service with a personal touch.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published